Beginning the
2013 season, the Blue Jays are looking at a familiar crowded bull-pen theme.
Due to the business side of baseball, the Jays may option some arms to AAA
despite perhaps being deserving of a MLB role. One of those people left behind
will not be Casey Janssen. However, Casey has been that victim of the numbers
game in the past, and he should serve as a ray of hope to any teammates that might
be dealing with a demotion.
A 29 year old
Casey Janssen was the odd-man out with a minor-league option on his contract as
Octavio Dotel was returning from the disabled list in April of 2011. The
alternative to sending Janssen down, at the time, was to release David Purcey:
The Jays 2004 first round draft pick who was out of options. Although Janssen
had decent numbers in 2010 (3.67 ERA and career relief ERA of 3.10), they
couldn't justify giving up on a former 1st rounder when Janssen could be
'banked' in AAA. So Janssen was sent down. That wasn't necessarily the first
disappointment Casey had faced since starting his MLB career.
Janssen had
aspirations as a career starting pitcher.
When he was originally called up to the Jays, it was in a starting role
to replace AJ Burnett in 2006. Then in 2007 he was asked to cover in the
bull-pen... where it turns out he thrived.
His bullpen ERA was 2.35 over 70 games, and he looked like he had found
a great every-day role. That is until a torn labrum required shoulder surgery,
and he spent the entire 2008 season on the DL. 2009 was a struggle for Janssen
to get back to full-strength as he did a couple of stints on the DL, spent 18
games in the minors, and put up unimpressive numbers at the MLB level. For his
2010 season, Janssen put some solid numbers together, stayed off the DL, and
proved that he was back, healthy and ready. So after the struggle to get back
to major league ball, his 2011 demotion to AAA must have felt like a kick in
the teeth.
I've heard
lots of interviews over the years where Casey Janssen has mentioned that he
wanted to be a starter, but he was willing to play wherever the team needed
him. He's always been that unselfish
team player, and I didn't hear complaints from him in the press when he was
sent down to AAA to start 2011. He accepted his unfair assignment in 2011; he
went down, pitched 7 shut-out innings over 6 games, and was on the next flight
back up when Toronto finally decided to release David Purcey on waivers. His
contract at that time was $1 million for 2011. On his 2011 recall, he put up a
2.54 ERA, 0.86 WHIP and went 6-0 as a reliever over 55 games. He parlayed those
numbers int a 5.9 million dollar contract for 2012/2013 with a $4 million team
option for 2012. He's run the gambit in terms of roles; starter, long reliever,
set-up guy, and now closer. He's done everything asked of him, and consistently carried that team-player
attitude that's made him the cornerstone of the 2013 bullpen.
There may be
a few disappointed pitchers spending time in AAA this season; JA Happ, Brad
Lincoln, Aaron Loup... and even Josh Thole for that matter (as a positional player). Hopefully they'll be able to look to the
example of Casey Janssen, and hold out hope that the best days are still to
come after the next recall - regardless of the 'fairness' of it all.